Makeup

The Best Cruelty Free Burgundy Mascaras for 2026, and How to Actually Wear Them

Warm-toned burgundy and plum cosmetics arranged on a soft cream vanity surface

The other morning I was at the mirror before the kids were up, doing the five-minute thing — the little face, the mascara, the coffee — and I kept reaching for a burgundy mascara I’d never actually bought. Because every time I’ve tried one, the brand wasn’t cruelty free. So I did what I always do: I went and found the ones that are.

Warm-toned burgundy and plum cosmetics arranged on a soft cream vanity surface

If you want the short answer: the best cruelty free burgundy mascaras you can buy right now are Kiko Milano Maxi Mod Color Mascara in 03 Plum, Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect in Burgundy, Too Faced Better Than Sex in Burgundy, Makeup Revolution Wrap Lash Tubing Mascara in Burgundy, and Glisten Cosmetics Spectra Lash in Maroon. On dark lashes, burgundy reads as a soft wine tint rather than a bright red — which makes it one of the easiest colored mascaras to wear every day. It’s especially flattering on green, hazel and blue-green eyes.

This post contains affiliate links, so I earn a small commission if you shop through them, at no extra cost to you.

The List I’d Actually Buy

Every mascara below comes from a brand that meets my cruelty free standard. I’ve noted which ones are vegan, because cruelty free and vegan are not the same thing. Prices were accurate when I updated this in November 2026.

1. Kiko Milano Maxi Mod Color Mascara in 03 Plum — €14,99

This is the one I wear. Plum is close to a burgundy wine, which is one of my favorite non-black mascara colors, and I haven’t had it smudge on me. The Maxi Mod wand is my number one for my eye shape — it’s small enough to reach the inner corners and the roots. One heads-up for vegan readers: Kiko lists carmine (CI 75470) as a color additive in this line, so it isn’t vegan.

2. Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara in Burgundy — $4.99

The cheapest way I know to try colored mascara. It’s the same Lash Princess so many of my readers swear by, with the conical fiber brush that’s thick at the base for volume and tapered at the tip so you can reach the inner corners. In Europe it runs about €4. Some reviewers say the color leans more brown than wine red, so expect a soft burgundy brown, not a vampy red. It isn’t waterproof, and Essence lists the Burgundy shade as vegan. It was sold out on Essence’s US site when I updated this post, so check Walmart or your local drugstore.

3. Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara in Burgundy — $29

The classic volumizer in a rich wine shade. The hourglass-shaped brush grabs, separates and curls, and the formula builds from a natural first coat to full drama by the third. The current formula is vegan. It’s not waterproof, so if you get transfer on your lid, do your lower lashes first and keep a metal lash comb handy for clumps. Burgundy is a limited edition shade, sold at Ulta in the US, so don’t wait if you want it. It’s £28 in the UK and €32 in Europe.

4. Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes Mascara in Dream Pop — $29

The softest shade on this list. Charlotte Tilbury calls it a berry brown, and it’s color-matched to the Pillow Talk Eyeliner, so expect a soft brown with a berry tint, not a vampy wine. If black mascara feels too harsh on you, this is the gentle way into color. The formula uses a lash-lifting polymer for a lifted look that the brand says lasts 24 hours, plus carnauba wax for volume. The two-sided brush has a flat side to load your lashes and a bristle side to comb them up and out. Reviewers love the shade on blue and green eyes, though some find the lift modest and say the flat brush takes practice. It’s water resistant, not waterproof. Charlotte Tilbury is cruelty free and Leaping Bunny approved, but this mascara isn’t vegan because the formula contains keratin. It’s $29 at Ulta, £28 in the UK and about €32 in Europe.

5. Makeup Revolution Wrap Lash Tubing Mascara in Burgundy — £10.99

If you want a burgundy that won’t smudge, go tubing. This one wraps each lash in tube-like polymers, so it’s water resistant and comes off with warm water — no remover needed. Revolution says it lasts 24 hours, and the formula has shea butter, carnauba wax and castor oil. It’s vegan, and Makeup Revolution is cruelty free. Reviewers with black lashes say the burgundy still shows. It’s easy to find in the UK and Europe at Superdrug and Beauty Bay. It’s $12 on Revolution’s US site, where it was sold out when I updated this post. In the US, Target carries Revolution’s Big Lash Mascara in Burgundy, which is a volumizing formula, not a tubing one.

6. Glisten Cosmetics Spectra Lash Mascara in Maroon — €15,95

The indie tubing mascara that comes in all the colors of the rainbow, and Maroon is the wine shade. If you want something brighter or more purple, look at Blood Red, Rose Red or Berry Purple. Glisten calls it a lengthening tubing formula, and it doesn’t clump on me. Vegan, according to the brand. Glisten’s White shade also works as a base coat underneath for full-strength color on dark lashes. It’s £10.50 in the UK.

7. VE Cosmetics Chroma Veil Coloured Mascara in Covenant — £12.99

VE Cosmetics is a vegan, cruelty free UK indie with a witchy streak I adore, and Covenant is the deep wine burgundy in their new Chroma Veil line. The Chroma Veil formula is water-based and buildable, with a slim silicone wand that keeps lashes separated, and it layers beautifully over black mascara. Chroma Veil replaces VE’s older colored mascaras. Covenant was showing as sold out when I updated this post in November 2026, so check the site for restocks.

8. Catrice Hyper Lash Mascara in 030 Burgundy Bliss — about €6

The easiest burgundy to find at European drugstores like Kruidvat, dm and Rossmann. Catrice is Essence’s sister brand. It’s cruelty free, and all Catrice products are vegan. Hyper Lash is a lengthening and volumizing mascara with a fiber brush, and Catrice describes the formula as buildable and free of alcohol and perfume. For a softer look, Catrice Pure Volume Magic Brown Mascara in 010 Burgundy Brown is a burgundy brown for about €4.

9. ColourPop BFF Volumizing Mascara in Wine O’Clock — $10

When I first wrote this post, the closest ColourPop had was a true red. Now the BFF Volumizing Mascara comes in Wine O’Clock, a rich burgundy, for $10 at Ulta. It isn’t waterproof. I’m including it because it’s easy to find in the US, but go in with realistic expectations. Reviews are mixed, and several reviewers with dark lashes say the color barely shows and the formula runs dry. If you have dark lashes, I’d start with one of the options above.

How to Wear Burgundy Mascara (the ways that work)

Deeper shades like burgundy and plum show as a tint on dark lashes. For more color, apply burgundy on the tips over black, or use a white or light base coat underneath. Here are the ways I actually wear it.

Pop of color on the lower lashes. The easiest way to start is burgundy on your lower lashes only, with black or nothing on top. It adds definition and a pop of color without committing to the full look. These days I wear burgundy mascara on both my upper and lower lashes. If you want the color more visible, try a white mascara primer underneath.

On the tips of your lashes. Apply your mascara as normal, then only apply the burgundy on the tips. Or put primer on the tips after your mascara, then the color on top of the primer.

Lashes only. A bare eye with only burgundy mascara. It’s softer than you’d think, and it’s my go-to on days I’m not doing a full face.

Monochromatic eyes. Burgundy eyeshadow, burgundy liner, burgundy mascara — the whole family in one look. It’s the most flattering way to wear it, in my opinion.

Coordinate the whole face. Match your mascara to your lipstick and your nails. It’s the kind of thing that makes a get-up feel intentional without you having to explain it to anyone.

Pair it with your favorite colors. Burgundy works with purple, black, rose gold, pink and peach. It also pairs well with brown and nude shades — I’d bet a soft mauve would look great too.

Lightly smokey. A lighter smokey eye in bronze or grey eyeshadow with burgundy mascara is the most wearable version of the look.

Why Burgundy, Anyway?

The number one reason is that I love burgundy almost as much as I love black and purple. It’s a jewel-toned color that really sets off my skin tone. And for my eye color — blue-green, which I don’t consider hazel because I don’t have any brown or amber in them — burgundy does something specific: it brings out the blue. Neutral shades like purple, cool shades like silver and lilac, and warm shades like peach, copper and bronze all work on my eyes too, but burgundy is the one that makes the blue pop.

The Flattest Combo for Your Eye Color

These are the most flattering eyeshadow and colored-mascara pairings I’ve seen makeup artists recommend, by eye color:

Brown eyes — gold eyeshadow, deep purple mascara. Amber eyes — terracotta eyeshadow, navy mascara. Hazel eyes — light purple eyeshadow, burgundy wine mascara. Green eyes — brown eyeshadow, burgundy wine mascara. Blue eyes — copper eyeshadow, navy mascara.

The Glow Ritual Tonight, before bed: take a clean spoolie and comb through your lashes one more time, then hold them up with a lash comb for 10 seconds. It’s five seconds of effort that makes tomorrow’s mascara sit cleaner, and it’s the difference between clumps and a clean, lifted line — no new product required.

Burgundy Mascara FAQ

What is the best cruelty free burgundy mascara?

For everyday wear, I like Kiko Milano Maxi Mod Color Mascara in 03 Plum. On a budget, Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara in Burgundy is $4.99. For big volume, go for Too Faced Better Than Sex in Burgundy. For a smudge-proof tubing formula, try Makeup Revolution Wrap Lash Tubing Mascara in Burgundy or Glisten Cosmetics Spectra Lash in Maroon. For a softer berry brown, try Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes in Dream Pop.

Is Maybelline Sky High in Burgundy Haze cruelty free? What about L’Oréal Voluminous in Deep Burgundy?

No. Maybelline and L’Oréal Paris are L’Oréal brands that sell in mainland China, so Sky High in Burgundy Haze, Voluminous Original in Deep Burgundy and Voluminous Panorama in Burgundy Cashmere are not cruelty free. The same goes for Clinique High Impact in Black Honey and Benefit BADgal BANG! in Wild Plum. Don’t trust a retailer badge — some shops put a “cruelty free” label on Maybelline, and that’s the retailer’s label, not a certification. For a similar drugstore burgundy, try Essence Lash Princess in Burgundy or Catrice Hyper Lash in Burgundy Bliss. For a prestige formula, try Too Faced Better Than Sex in Burgundy or Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes in Dream Pop.

Which burgundy mascaras are vegan?

Makeup Revolution Wrap Lash, Catrice Hyper Lash, VE Cosmetics Chroma Veil and the current Too Faced Better Than Sex formula are vegan. Essence lists Lash Princess in Burgundy as vegan, and Glisten Cosmetics says Spectra Lash is vegan. Kiko Maxi Mod Color Mascara is not vegan because it contains carmine, and Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes is not vegan because it contains keratin.

What eye color does burgundy mascara look best on?

Green and hazel eyes get the most contrast, because red-based shades sit opposite green on the color wheel. It’s also beautiful on blue-green eyes, where it brings out the blue. Brown eyes get a soft warmth from burgundy, though purple and navy make brown eyes pop more.

Does burgundy mascara show up on dark lashes?

It shows as a tint, not a bright color. Deeper shades like plum and burgundy read as a soft wine tone on dark lashes, so apply them on the tips over black, or wear them on their own on lighter lashes. For full-strength color, use a white or light base coat underneath — Glisten’s White shade works for this.

Is burgundy mascara more natural looking than black?

On fair skin and lighter lashes, yes. Burgundy is softer than black, so it defines your lashes without the harsh contrast. On dark lashes it looks close to black indoors and shows its wine tint in daylight.

What is the difference between burgundy, plum and brown mascara?

Burgundy is a deep red wine shade. Plum leans more purple, and burgundy brown shades are softer and more neutral. Kiko’s 03 Plum is close to a burgundy wine, while Essence’s Burgundy, Catrice’s Burgundy Brown and Charlotte Tilbury’s Dream Pop sit closer to brown. If you’re nervous about color, start with a burgundy brown.

Does burgundy mascara make your eyes look red or tired?

It can if you pick a bright red shade, or if your eyes or lids are already pink. A deep wine, plum or burgundy brown is the safer choice, and it helps to keep the color on your lashes and away from the waterline. If you’re unsure, start with burgundy on your lower lashes or just the tips.

Is there a cruelty free tubing or waterproof burgundy mascara?

For tubing, yes: Makeup Revolution Wrap Lash Tubing Mascara in Burgundy and Glisten Cosmetics Spectra Lash in Maroon. Tubing formulas are water resistant, not waterproof. Sweat, humidity and a few tears are fine, swimming is not. I couldn’t find a cruelty free burgundy mascara sold as waterproof when I updated this post.

Can you wear burgundy mascara with hooded eyes?

Yes. Choose a formula that won’t transfer onto the hood when you blink — which is why I like tubing formulas — and a small wand that reaches the inner corners. Keep the volume on the outer two thirds so the lid doesn’t look heavier.

A note from Johnson: I bought burgundy mascara before I had a reason to. I just liked the color, and I didn’t care if the brand wasn’t clean. What changed for me wasn’t a new formula — it was realizing that I could have the color I want without the compromise. That’s the whole point of this list.

Do you wear burgundy mascara? Which one is your favorite, and is there a cruelty free one I should try next? Let me know in the comments.

Glow is a habit, not a product.

Keep Reading

Leave a Comment